• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Larry Brown Sports

Larry Brown Sports

Brown Bag it, Baby

  • Home
  • Blog View
  • NFL
  • NCAAF
  • NBA
  • MLB
  • Media
  • Headlines
  • Podcast
BaseballAlex Rodriguez

Alex Rodriguez voted most overrated player in baseball by SI players’ poll

July 6, 2012 by Larry Brown • Comments
FacebookTweetLinkedInRedditThreadsWhatsAppEmail
Add as a preferred source on Google

Sports Illustrated released the results of its latest poll which asked MLB players to name the most overrated position player in baseball. Surprise surprise, Alex Rodriguez topped the list. The Yankees third baseman captured a strong percentage of the vote:

    1. Alex Rodriguez (16.8%)
    2. Derek Jeter (9.2%)
    3. Jayson Werth (6%)
    4. Nick Swisher (5.4%)
    5. Albert Pujols (4.7%)
    6. Ichiro Suzuki (3.4%)
    7. Hanley Ramirez (2.5%)
    8. Jason Heyward (2.3%)
    9. David Wright (2.1%)
    10. Coco Crisp (1.8%)

I know it’s fashionable to take shots at A-Rod — and believe me, we’ve done our fair share here at LBS — but there’s a lot to be said about making the list. Much like the way Reggie Jackson says “they don’t boo nobodies,” you don’t make this list if you haven’t done something in the game. I would take these 10 “overrated” players on my team and see you in the World Series.

There is only one player on the list who is different from the others, and that is Jason Heyward. He could belong on an overhyped list. When it comes to the rest of the players, I see a bunch of guys who are making a ton of money and not earning it this year (except for David Wright).

H/T Hot Clicks

  • Have Questions? Get Answers!

  • i want more great stories!

Sign up today for free and get the best sports content sent to your inbox.

You can unsubscribe anytime. For more details, review our Privacy Policy.

.

Follow Us

Get instantly notified of the most viral news stories via Google!

  • Trending stories

Jameis Winston doing a hilarious hard count during Giants-Commanders game

Jameis Winston had fans in stitches over his outlandish hard count on TNF

6 days ago
James Cook with a stain on his pants

Bills’ James Cook addresses the claim that he pooped his pants during game

November 10, 2026
LSU coach Lane Kiffing crying after losing to Texas

Lane Kiffin seen crying after LSU’s choke job against Texas

4 days ago
Terry Bradshaw before a game

Terry Bradshaw has clueless moment on FOX pregame show

3 days ago
LeBron James looking on

LeBron James made a surprising request of 76ers coaches

2 days ago

Sidebar


  • don’t miss these

A Yankees hat

Report: Yankees could hire 1 former rival manager

4 hours ago65
Sonny Gray in his Red Sox uniform

Sonny Gray lands $55 million deal with 1 of his former teams

7 hours ago35
A Boston Red Sox hat

Red Sox acquire catcher from Rays in AL East swap

8 hours ago152
Tarik Skubal in his Dodgers uniform

Tarik Skubal sweepstakes could come down to 2 teams

9 hours ago84
A Seattle Mariners hat

Mariners acquire Gold Glove third baseman in 6-player trade involving Royals

11 hours ago156
Dustin May in a Dodgers cap

Dustin May lands $52 million deal with AL team

1 day ago55
  • popular stories

Kyle Whittingham walking away

Curious video of Kyle Whittingham draws attention during Michigan’s loss

Aaron Rodgers in a Steelers hoodie

Aaron Rodgers shares unexpected photo with brother Jordan

Ohio Stadium exterior

Ohio State bettors had the worst bad beat to end Saturday’s game

Aidan Hutchinson on the sideline

Lions get bad news on Aidan Hutchinson’s celebration injury

Kirk Cousins smiles

Kirk Cousins leaves a classy message for Fernando Mendoza

Dianna Russini holding a mic

Dianna Russini’s new show got very awkward after a Mike Vrabel mention

Get the App

© 2026 · LB Sports Media Group Inc · Powered by Springwire.ai

Privacy Manager © 2026 · All Rights Reserved
  • X
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • RSS Feed
  • About Larry Brown Sports
  • Contact
  • Editorial Process
  • Staff Writers
  • Privacy Policy
Dedicated to the memory of Nevil Vega
Team/Player Stats