• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Larry Brown Sports

Larry Brown Sports

Brown Bag it, Baby

  • Home
  • Blog View
  • NFL
  • NCAAF
  • NBA
  • MLB
  • Media
  • Headlines
  • Podcast
BaseballAlex Rodriguez

Alex Rodriguez voted most overrated player in baseball by SI players’ poll

July 6, 2012 by Larry Brown • Comments
FacebookTweetLinkedInRedditThreadsWhatsAppEmail

Sports Illustrated released the results of its latest poll which asked MLB players to name the most overrated position player in baseball. Surprise surprise, Alex Rodriguez topped the list. The Yankees third baseman captured a strong percentage of the vote:

    1. Alex Rodriguez (16.8%)
    2. Derek Jeter (9.2%)
    3. Jayson Werth (6%)
    4. Nick Swisher (5.4%)
    5. Albert Pujols (4.7%)
    6. Ichiro Suzuki (3.4%)
    7. Hanley Ramirez (2.5%)
    8. Jason Heyward (2.3%)
    9. David Wright (2.1%)
    10. Coco Crisp (1.8%)

I know it’s fashionable to take shots at A-Rod — and believe me, we’ve done our fair share here at LBS — but there’s a lot to be said about making the list. Much like the way Reggie Jackson says “they don’t boo nobodies,” you don’t make this list if you haven’t done something in the game. I would take these 10 “overrated” players on my team and see you in the World Series.

There is only one player on the list who is different from the others, and that is Jason Heyward. He could belong on an overhyped list. When it comes to the rest of the players, I see a bunch of guys who are making a ton of money and not earning it this year (except for David Wright).

H/T Hot Clicks

  • i want more great stories!

Sign up today for free and get the best sports content sent to your inbox.

You can unsubscribe anytime. For more details, review our Privacy Policy.

.

Follow Us

Get instantly notified of the most viral news stories via Google!

  • Trending stories

Dallas Cowboys field logo

Cowboys have chosen a new defensive coordinator

6 days ago
The Baltimore Ravens logo at midfield

Ravens have hired their next head coach

6 days ago
Keon Coleman taking the field

Report reveals Keon Coleman’s reaction to Bills owner throwing him under the bus

5 days ago
Sean Payton on the sideline

Sean Payton gets slammed for his ‘arrogance’ on call that swung Broncos-Patriots game

3 days ago
An NFL shield logo

NFL addresses wild conspiracy theory about Super Bowl matchup

2 days ago

Sidebar


  • don’t miss these

Mariners star Eugenio Suarez at a press conference after Game 5 of the ALCS

Eugenio Suarez linked to 3 teams in MLB free agency

1 day ago1K+
Bo Bichette in the dugout

Carlos Mendoza weighs in on Bo Bichette’s crucial adjustment

2 days ago98
The Angels logo at Angel Stadium

Angels taking chance on former 35-HR hitter

2 days ago589
Justin Verlander in a Giants uniform

Justin Verlander linked to 1 team in free agent rumors

2 days ago1K+
A Kansas City Royals hat and glove

Royals land former World Series-winning pitcher

2 days ago122
Nathan Eovaldi delivers a pitch

Nathan Eovaldi provides a significant 2026 update

3 days ago148
  • popular stories

A Raiders helmet

Prime candidate emerges for Raiders head coach job

Tennis bad girl Yulia Putintseva mocks booing crowd with dance.

Tennis bad girl mocks Australian Open crowd with sultry dance

Pittsburgh Steelers helmet

Steelers have hired a new head coach

Jonathan Kuminga grinning while warming up

Warriors considering Jonathan Kuminga trade for former Golden State All-Star

Mark Fletcher being held back

Mark Fletcher throws punch at Tyrique Tucker after Miami’s loss

Shedeur Sanders in Browns jersey

Everyone said the same thing about Shedeur Sanders’ Pro Bowl selection

Get the App

© 2026 · LB Sports Media Group Inc · Powered by Springwire.ai

  • X
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • RSS Feed
  • About Larry Brown Sports
  • Contact
  • Editorial Process
  • Staff Writers
  • Privacy Policy
Dedicated to the memory of Nevil Vega