Comments on: Kurt Warner … Hall of Famer http://larrybrownsports.com/football/kurt-warner-not-hall-of-famer/5045 Brown Bag it, Baby Mon, 13 Feb 2012 19:05:00 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: SpinMax http://larrybrownsports.com/football/kurt-warner-not-hall-of-famer/5045/comment-page-1#comment-468579 SpinMax Sat, 31 Jan 2009 13:03:04 +0000 http://larrybrownsports.com/?p=5045#comment-468579 McNabb and the China doll have both missed about the same number of games due to injury McNabb and the China doll have both missed about the same number of games due to injury

]]> By: Gene http://larrybrownsports.com/football/kurt-warner-not-hall-of-famer/5045/comment-page-1#comment-467899 Gene Fri, 30 Jan 2009 17:24:08 +0000 http://larrybrownsports.com/?p=5045#comment-467899 Max, I saw Cardinal receivers running in the open all game and McNabb trying to squeeze the ball into tight openings where Eagle receivers had no separation. Do you really believe that if the teams switched QB's Warner would even have the Eagles in the game? What about all of the seasons McNabb played injured and still got the Eagles to the playoffs while Warner, the china doll, coughed the ball up and missed games? Max, I saw Cardinal receivers running in the open all game and McNabb trying to squeeze the ball into tight openings where Eagle receivers had no separation. Do you really believe that if the teams switched QB’s Warner would even have the Eagles in the game? What about all of the seasons McNabb played injured and still got the Eagles to the playoffs while Warner, the china doll, coughed the ball up and missed games?

]]> By: SpinMax http://larrybrownsports.com/football/kurt-warner-not-hall-of-famer/5045/comment-page-1#comment-466925 SpinMax Thu, 29 Jan 2009 23:07:49 +0000 http://larrybrownsports.com/?p=5045#comment-466925 McNabb better than Warner? did you miss that game 2 weeks ago when Warner got it done in the clutch while McNabb choked and repeatedly missed wide open guys even on short passes? Much like their careers. The only thing they have in common is injury problems leading to poor seasons. McNabb better than Warner? did you miss that game 2 weeks ago when Warner got it done in
the clutch while McNabb choked and repeatedly missed wide open guys even on short passes?
Much like their careers. The only thing they have in common is injury problems leading to
poor seasons.

]]> By: NICK http://larrybrownsports.com/football/kurt-warner-not-hall-of-famer/5045/comment-page-1#comment-466835 NICK Thu, 29 Jan 2009 21:09:42 +0000 http://larrybrownsports.com/?p=5045#comment-466835 Gene makes a very good point. Warner is a good QB and i think that the Cards have some choices to make. Drafted Matt Lienart # 10 overall and hasnt been good. Gene makes a very good point. Warner is a good QB and i think that the Cards have some choices to make. Drafted Matt Lienart # 10 overall and hasnt been good.

]]> By: Gene http://larrybrownsports.com/football/kurt-warner-not-hall-of-famer/5045/comment-page-1#comment-466811 Gene Thu, 29 Jan 2009 20:35:18 +0000 http://larrybrownsports.com/?p=5045#comment-466811 Warner should not be in the HOF. He is very successful in the proper system - either with the great Cardinal receivers or with the Rams' greatest show on turf. However, when he is with an average offense, he played very average, as you have pointed out. By way of comparison, Tom Brady guided the Patriots to the playoffs many times with receivers who are, for the most part, nameless. When he finally got Moss and Welker, he set records and came within one minute of an unthinkable perfect season. McNabb hasn't won the big game, but, for the most part, he has labored with average receiving talent. He has taken the Eagles a lot farther than Warner would have with similar players around him. For my money, he is the better QB. If Super Bowl rings were the sole criterion on which to judge quarterbacks, you would have to rate Trent Dilfer above Dan Marino. Warner should not be in the HOF. He is very successful in the proper system – either with the great Cardinal receivers or with the Rams’ greatest show on turf. However, when he is with an average offense, he played very average, as you have pointed out. By way of comparison, Tom Brady guided the Patriots to the playoffs many times with receivers who are, for the most part, nameless. When he finally got Moss and Welker, he set records and came within one minute of an unthinkable perfect season.

McNabb hasn’t won the big game, but, for the most part, he has labored with average receiving talent. He has taken the Eagles a lot farther than Warner would have with similar players around him. For my money, he is the better QB.

If Super Bowl rings were the sole criterion on which to judge quarterbacks, you would have to rate Trent Dilfer above Dan Marino.

]]>