College basketball fans were very unhappy to see one arguably undeserving team selected for the NCAA Tournament field.
The Virginia Cavaliers were selected for the 68-team field, getting a First Four game against Colorado State as a No. 10 seed. The winner will play the Texas Longhorns in the round of 64.
Virginia’s inclusion was immediately controversial. The team went 23-10, but advanced metrics do not rate the team highly. They have not beaten an NCAA Tournament team since Feb. 3, and their most impressive win of the season was arguably against Florida all the way back in November. The Cavaliers have also lost in blowouts against Virginia Tech and Notre Dame.
The mediocre resume, combined with the team’s slow, unappealing style of play, led to many fans and even some experts ripping the committee for their inclusion. Several excluded bubble teams that rated more highly than Virginia in some metrics, including Seton Hall, St. John’s, and Indiana State, were named as alternatives.
I'd watch Indiana State players park cars before watching this Virginia team play basketball in the NCAA Tournament
— Brendan Quinn (@BFQuinn) March 17, 2024
Virginia is 4-5 in its last nine games and hasn't beaten an NCAA tournament team since Feb. 3. https://t.co/8upepvcEME
— Pat Forde (@ByPatForde) March 17, 2024
the selection committee putting virginia in the tourney this year pic.twitter.com/GEJkXDlnTm
— Annie Agar (@AnnieAgar) March 17, 2024
Virginia went 2-7 in Q1 games
They are #69 on KenPom
The Strength of Schedule was #77Seton Hall went 5-8 in Q1 games
They are #62 on KenPom
The Strength of Schedule was #42The Committee went with Virginia
— Ryan Cassidy (@ryancassidycbb) March 17, 2024
Pitt had a better NET, KenPom, BPI, overall strength of schedule and Quad 1 record than Virginia AND BEAT VIRGINIA BY DOUBLE DIGITS IN CHARLOTTESVILLE.
But Virginia is in, and Pitt is out.
Ridiculous.
— Josh Rowntree (@JRown32) March 17, 2024
Virginia with a NET of 54 and 2-7 Quad 1 record is in. Doesn't make sense.
— Zach Braziller (@NYPost_Brazille) March 17, 2024
Virginia’s 13-7 ACC record was probably decisive in getting them into the field. On the other hand, Clemson got a No. 6 seed after going 11-9, while Pittsburgh was excluded despite going 12-8 and beating Virginia in their only meeting of the season.
The Cavaliers’ inclusion might have been less controversial had they managed the end of their last ACC Tournament game more capably. Ultimately, though, their poor resume and reputation for flaming out early in the NCAA Tournament ensures that they are an unpopular selection.
