Quantcast

Conference Tournament Results Weighed Too Heavily on Tourney Seedings

I’m not a fan of conference tournaments for several reasons. For starters, it cheapens the regular season. Think about the smaller conferences that don’t get at-large bids — Weber State for instance goes 15-1 in the Big Sky but loses in the conference tourney and goes home. Davidson was 18-2 in Southern Conference play, but Chattanooga gets hot in the tourney and steals the automatic bid and Davidson is NIT bound. Additionally, the made-for-TV tourneys allow teams like DePaul (that was 0-18 in Big East play) a chance to earn an automatic bid into the NCAA tournament. Imagine 1-17 Indiana playing for the national championship because they stole the Big 10 tourney. It would be totally bunk. Furthermore, they play games in four straight days, something that isn’t done all season, and isn’t even done in the actual NCAA Tournament. And worst of all, conference tourney results had to strong a bearing on the seedings.

Let me start off with the SEC, which only got three teams into the tourney because experts said they had a “down year.” LSU for example dominated conference play going 13-3. They were a top 25 team considering they had only lost 6 games all year. Because they lost in the second round of the SEC tourney they go from a team ranked 20th (which translates to a 5 seed) to an 8 seed? Tennessee despite non-conference wins over Marquette and Georgetown drops to a 9 seed because of a finals loss to Mississippi State? What would they have been, a 6, had they won the conference tourney? Then you get Duke and Wake Forest, both with 11-5 records in the ACC, behind only North Carolina. The teams split in conference play, and Wake actually beat UNC, unlike Duke. Yet the Blue Devils win the ACC tourney while Wake drops only one effing game to Maryland, and now Duke’s a 2 and Wake’s a 4.

Then in my home conference, the Pac-10, you see the same thing. UCLA loses to USC in the conference tournament, and they go from being ranked 15th which translates to a 4 seed, to getting a six seed. Someone tell me why one game in a conference tournament should carry so much more weight than the 18 games most of these teams play in their conference regular season. It doesn’t make any sense except for the purpose of generating TV excitement.

The results of these conference tourneys are so erratic, that they become almost impossible to pick. You never know who’s showing up and actually trying to win the thing. That’s also why we must give props to The Driver who won the LBS conference tourney picks contest by correctly selecting two of the six conference tourney winners, Purdue and Louisville. Hopefully he’ll enjoy the No Fear swag that comes as the prize.



Around The Web

  • JS

    Amazing how much emphasis the NCAA puts into the conference tournaments and then refuses to consider a football tournament, trying to tell us that the BCS works.

  • http://www.UCLAradio.com the driver

    count it…patting myself on the back

  • Jeff J

    The conference tournament results weighing in seeding is ridiculous. The teams that are already in the big dance don’t want waste their energy playing 3 conference games, so they drop one. It shouldn’t affect their standing in the seedings.

  • Gene

    Conference tournaments are ridiculous because at no other time, during the regular season or the NCAA tournament, do teams play back to back let alone three or four consecutive days. Why are those games more important than the regular season games against the same opponent?

    Reader Jeff J is right. many of the teams already in the tournament tank. Arizona under Lute Olson is an example where the coach liberally used his bench so that his team would be primed for the NCAA run.

    It is especially ludicrous in the Pac 10, where everyone plays a balanced home and home schedule with everyone else. What is there left to prove?

  • Jeff J

    Speaking of Arizona, I can’t believe Arizona even made the tournament this year. This won’t be the first year they lose in the first round. At least this team will deserve to do so.